I have to agree with the majority of the reviewers, WHH makes a quality product whether you order a complete holster or just the Kydex replacement. I have ordered several complete holsters and magazine holsters as well as several of the Kydex replacements.over the years. My personal preference is for the horsehide backer in the IWB. If you sweat at all, you will certainly appreciate the advantages of horsehide. For the magazine holster, I usually opt for the OWB as it just more comfortable than trying to stuff the gun and magazine holsters inside your pants. I have always found the quality of their products to be top notch, and I have never had any issues with the leather or Kydex. I prefer to stay with the Maxtuck/Maxslide replacement Kydex so I can stay with the same backer for different pistols. One item of note is that when I am training, I have never had any issues with either the pistol or magazines accidentally coming out of their respective holsters. Everything stays put where it belongs. As many reviewers have noted, it is a great product for a fair price. You can't get much better than that.